Custom 1st Birthday Cookies

Custom 1st Birthday Cookies

Filter

Custom 1st Birthday Cookies

FeaturedBest sellingAlphabetically, A-ZAlphabetically, Z-APrice, low to highPrice, high to lowDate, old to newDate, new to old
Filters
Out of stock
Product type
Sort by
One-der-ful Photo Pink - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
1.75 ea.
Wild One Birthday - Chocolate Chip Mini Cookies (2 oz) W/ Full Color Custom Sticker & Ribbon
As low as
$1.88 ea.
Build Your Own - Photo Upload, Message & Color - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
1.75 ea.
+ 11 more
First Birthday Pretty Pink Florals - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.59 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
One-der-ful Photo Blue - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
1.75 ea.
Create your own Photo & Message - Chocolate Chip Mini Cookies (2 oz) W/ Full Color Custom Sticker & Ribbon
As low as
$1.88 ea.
+ 11 more
Custom 1st Birthday Cookies
Wild One Birthday - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.59 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
Custom 1st Birthday Cookies
First Birthday Pretty Pink Florals - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
1.75 ea.
Build your Own Photo Design & Color - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.59 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
+ 11 more
Wild One Photo - Personalized Direct Print on Rectangle Sugar Cookies
As low as
2.29 ea.
One-der-ful Photo Pink - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.59 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
The Big One - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
1.75 ea.
One-der-ful Photo Blue - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.59 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
Pretty Pink Florals Photo - Personalized Direct Print on Rectangle Sugar Cookies
As low as
2.29 ea.
Wild One Birthday - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
1.75 ea.
The Big One Crown Photo - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.59 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
Watercolor Stars & Candle First Birthday - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.59 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
Jungle Birthday Photo - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.59 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
Create your own Photo & Message - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
1.75 ea.
Princess Party - Chocolate Chip Mini Cookies (2 oz) W/ Full Color Custom Sticker & Ribbon
As low as
$1.88 ea.

Custom First Birthday Cookies

Celebrate your baby’s biggest milestone with custom 1st birthday cookies made fresh for the occasion. A first birthday is a moment you’ll always remember, and custom cookies are a simple way to make it feel even more special. Choose from direct-print sugar cookies or gourmet flavors, all individually wrapped and made with high-quality ingredients. These cookies are perfect for dessert tables, party favors, or sharing with family and friends.

First Birthday Themes and Designs

Match your cookies to your party theme with fully customizable designs. Whether you’re planning something classic, playful, or modern, our cookies can be designed to fit your vision. Popular first birthday themes include animals, soft pastels, and simple “one” designs that highlight the milestone. Every cookie is made to look clean, bright, and ready to stand out.

Gourmet Cookie Options

Looking for more variety? Our gourmet cookies are a great option for guests who want something beyond a traditional sugar cookie. Each one is individually wrapped and finished with a full-color custom sticker that matches your first birthday design. They’re easy to hand out and work well for both small gatherings and larger parties.

First Birthday Cookie Favors

Custom cookies make great party favors for a first birthday. Hand them out to guests or display them as part of your setup. With individual wrapping and custom designs, they’re easy to distribute and add a polished touch to your celebration.

Future Ordering

With our future ordering option, you can place your cookie order early and choose your exact delivery date. This helps you lock in your design, quantity, and details ahead of time, so everything is ready when the party gets closer. It’s a simple way to stay organized and avoid last-minute stress while making sure your First birthday cookies arrive fresh and on schedule.