Personalized New Year's Cookies

Personalized New Year's Cookies

Filter

Personalized New Year's Cookies

FeaturedBest sellingAlphabetically, A-ZAlphabetically, Z-APrice, low to highPrice, high to lowDate, old to newDate, new to old
Filters
Out of stock
Price
$
$
Product type
Sort by
NYE 2025 Logo Upload & Message - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.40 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
Happy New Year Cheer - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
$1.99 ea.
Happy New Year Starburst - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
$1.99 ea.
Happy New Year Cheer - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie w/ Gift Bag & Matching Bow
As low as
$2.98 ea.
Happy New Year Cheer - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker w/ Gift Bag & Matching Bow
As low as
2.39 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
NYE 2025 Logo Upload & Message - Gourmet Chocolate Chip or Variety Pack w/ Full Color Personalized Sticker Gift Box
As low as
$23.99 ea.
Options
NYE 2025 Logo Upload & Message - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker w/ Gift Bag & Matching Bow
As low as
2.39 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
NYE Celebration - Personalized Direct Print on Round Sugar Cookie Gift Box
As low as
$32.99 ea.
NYE Celebration - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.40 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
New Years Eve Logo Upload - Personalized Direct Print on Round Sugar Cookie Gift Box
As low as
$32.99 ea.
Happy New Year Starburst Strip - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.40 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
NYE Celebration - Gourmet Chocolate Chip or Variety Pack w/ Full Color Personalized Sticker Gift Box
As low as
$23.99 ea.
Options
New Years Eve Logo Upload - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
$1.99 ea.
Happy New Year Silver Ball Drop - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.40 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
Happy New Year Starburst - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.40 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
NYE Cheers Disco Ball - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.40 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
Happy New Year Cheer - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.40 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
Happy New Year Silver Ball Drop - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
$1.99 ea.
NYE 2024 Celebration - Personalized Direct Print On Rectangle Sugar Cookie
As low as
$2.39 ea.
Happy New Year Starburst - Personalized Direct Print On Square Sugar Cookie
As low as
$2.19 ea.
NYE Cheers Disco Ball - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
$1.99 ea.

Custom New Year's Eve Decorated Cookies

Ring in the new year with our festive, personalized New Year's Eve cookies! Made with premium ingredients including real butter and sugar, these decorated cookies are perfect for countdown parties, family gatherings, and midnight celebrations. Choose from our royal icing sugar cookies with elegant champagne glass images or indulge in decadent flavors like Chocolate Chunk or Salted Caramel cookies to make your New Year's celebrations memorable.

Celebrate with Personalized New Years Cookies

Add a personal touch to your New Years cookies with custom messages, family photos, or festive designs. Our cookie decorating expertise ensures each cookie is a beautiful edible keepsake. Whether you prefer our gluten-free options or classic recipes with sprinkles and gold accents, your guests will love these sweet treats. Order your New Years Eve cookies early to ensure delivery before December's end—these dough delights make the perfect companion for champagne toasts when the clock strikes midnight!