See What Our Customers Are Saying!

Based on 396 reviews
Very Average

Positive - The cookies arrived exactly when they were supposed to. Printing was good and as expected.
Negative - we ordered the chocolate chip cookies and they tasted very average. They were pretty dry and firm. The quality did not meet the price.

Personalized Graduation Year / Cap Photo- Direct Print on Rectangle Sugar Cookies


the cookies were fresh and delicious. The picture came out just like we wanted! I will definitely order them again!

Good taste, but no ingredient list.

The cookies came out well and tasted good, but majority of customers did not partake because of a lack of ingredient list/allergy information. The boxes shipped without an included ingredient list/allergy information as well, so we could not supplement with this.

Great customization

The picture printed great on the cookies, and they all stayed so fresh and soft! Great product.

Couldn't Have Asked For More

First time order, so I didn't know what to expect. The cookies were fresh, none were broken, the quality of the printing was more than I could have expected, and the cookies have an amazing taste. Worked with customer service rep D. Cohen. She was wonderful, quick to respond, and did all she could to assist in making sure our logo was lined up correctly. Can't wait to place another order! Thank you, Incredible Cookies, for an outstanding experience.

They came quickly and exactly what I wanted ! The tball team and Parebts were so impressed and happy!

Great purchase, highly recommend!

We ordered these cookies for our company event and they arrived in great condition and were good quality. The cookies were tasty and were a wonderful addition to our event. We will be ordering again the next time we need cookies for an event!

Loved it

Made a very last minute order, Debbie helped me over the phone and followed up after I placed the order. Great experience and the cookies came out very cute!

Excellent service and cookies!

Our cookies arrived on time and packaged well--- there was no broken pieces or unusable cookies. We did one cookie with our logo on the sticker of the package and one where the logo was printed on the cookie itself and they both looked fantastic and tasted great too.

Just OK

Shipping was quick but the cookies were dry and not much flavor. Emailed customer service regarding the above but did not receive a response.

Personalized Graduation "Congrats Class of" Direct Print on Rectangle Sugar Cookies

Super cute and tasty

I was nervous about these but they came quick, tasted good and were absolutely perfect!!!


I submitted a photo for custom printing on square cookies and they were a hit for our party. Arrived quickly and each one perfect. Very pleased!

Great Birthday Gift for a College Boy

I had the cookie sandwich kit delivered to my sons dorm for his birthday during finals week. It was reasonably priced and my son said everything was absolutely delicious.

Hoot! Hoot!

The FAU cookies were a big hit! Fabulous presentation & quite tasty.

Upload Your Own Logo - Incredible Chocolate Chip Cookie w/ Full Color Personalized sticker - 1.5oz

Truly incredible!

I order cookies for my daughter’s college bed party with her university’s mascot. They came out amazing!!!
I wanted to confirm delivery as I ordered a couple of days before and Steve responded immediately and after business hours. The cookies came packaged very well, were in perfect condition and included a free sample cookie along with the 10 ordered. Service and quality were super!

Center of Attention

We used the cookies at our Prom. The students absolutely loved them. They were the center of attention! Debbie did a great job, and the cookies tasted so good!!

Loved the cookies

The cookies were personalized for my daughter’s graduation. Not only was the picture and printing good on the cookie, the cookie itself was very good. I would certainly recommend to all.

Custom Company Logo Cookies

Logo turned out great! Incredible Cookies was great to work with and have a fast turn around time!

Moms Loved the Cookies!

We ordered 400 Best Mom Ever cookies and they were phenomenal! The cookies were subtly sweet and even though the print was brightly colored, it tasted good and not bitter at all. 10 cookies were broken but that's expected with a bulk order. We will absolutely be ordering for many future events!

Easy and tasty

I used Incredible Cookies for a client luncheon, as a thank you. The cookies were very good and the company logo/ image I gave them looked great. It was easy to order online and they sent extra cookies to account for breakage. That was great because we did have some cookies break in route. We had plenty, though, because of the extras they sent. I would use them again for sure.

OOT Dinner Cookies

What a hit !!! The cookies tasted as good as they looked ……….


These cookies were perfect. They tasted great and delivery was fast. I will definitely order again!