Custom First Communion Cookies

Custom First Communion Cookies

Filter

Custom First Communion Cookies

FeaturedMost relevantBest sellingAlphabetically, A-ZAlphabetically, Z-APrice, low to highPrice, high to lowDate, old to newDate, new to old
Filters
Out of stock
Product type
Sort by
First Holy Communion Greenery Banner Girl - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
1.75 ea.
God Bless Simple Cross - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker w/ Gift Bag & Matching Bow
As low as
$2.84 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
Personalized Communion "God Bless Simple Cross" Direct Print on Round Sugar Cookies
As low as
1.75 ea.
Pink Stripes Communion - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie w/ Gift Bag & Matching Bow
As low as
3.00 ea.
Communion Simple Cross Photo - Pink - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
1.69 ea.
Simple Floral Cross Communion - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker w/ Gift Bag & Matching Bow
As low as
$2.84 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
Custom First Communion Cookies
First Holy Communion Greenery Banner Girl - Chocolate Chip Mini Cookies (2 oz) W/ Full Color Custom Sticker & Ribbon
As low as
$1.88 ea.
Custom First Communion Cookies
Communion Florals and Feathers - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
1.69 ea.
Simple Floral Cross Communion - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie w/ Gift Bag & Matching Bow
As low as
3.00 ea.
First Holy Communion Greenery Banner Boy - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
1.75 ea.
Pink Stripes Communion - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker w/ Gift Bag & Matching Bow
As low as
$2.84 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
God Bless Simple Cross - Chocolate Chip Mini Cookies (2 oz) W/ Full Color Custom Sticker & Ribbon
As low as
$1.88 ea.
Pink Stripes Communion - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
1.75 ea.
May God Bless Pink - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.59 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
Communion Simple Cross Photo - Pink - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.59 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
Pink Stripes Communion - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.59 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
Communion Florals and Feathers - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.59 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
May God Bless Pink Photo - Personalized Direct Print on Rectangle Sugar Cookie
As low as
2.29 ea.
Pink Rosary Chalice - Gourmet Chocolate Chip Or Variety Pack W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$1.59 ea.
Includes 20% OFF
Options
Florals and Feathers Communion - Personalized Direct Print on Square Sugar Cookies
As low as
$1.99 ea.
May God Bless Pink - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
1.75 ea.
God Bless Banner Pink - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
1.75 ea.
Pink Rosary Chalice - Personalized Direct Print On Round Sugar Cookie
As low as
1.75 ea.
Pink Stripes Communion - Personalized Direct Print on Square Sugar Cookies
As low as
$1.99 ea.
Pink Rosary Chalice - Personalized Direct Print on Square Sugar Cookies
As low as
$1.99 ea.
God Bless Simple Cross - Gourmet Chocolate Chip or Variety Pack w/ Full Color Personalized Sticker Gift Box
As low as
$39.99 ea.
FREE shipping Gift sets only
Use Code: GIFTSET25
Options
First Holy Communion Greenery Banner Girl - Gourmet Chocolate Chip or Variety Pack w/ Full Color Personalized Sticker Gift Box
As low as
$39.99 ea.
FREE shipping Gift sets only
Use Code: GIFTSET25
Options
First Holy Communion Greenery Banner Girl - Fudge Brownies W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$2.49 ea.
Options
God Bless Simple Cross Photo Girl - Fudge Brownies W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$2.49 ea.
Options
God Bless Banner Pink - Fudge Brownies W/ Full Color Personalized Sticker
As low as
$2.49 ea.
Options
First Holy Communion Greenery Banner Girl - Personalized Direct Print on Round Sugar Cookie Gift Box
As low as
$50.39 ea.
FREE shipping Gift sets only
Use Code: GIFTSET25
God Bless Simple Cross - Personalized Direct Print on Round Sugar Cookie Gift Box
As low as
$50.39 ea.
FREE shipping Gift sets only
Use Code: GIFTSET25
God Bless Banner Pink - Chocolate Chip Mini Cookies (2 oz) W/ Full Color Custom Sticker & Ribbon
As low as
$1.88 ea.
Pink God Bless Simple Cross Photo Girl - Chocolate Chip Mini Cookies (2 oz) W/ Full Color Custom Sticker & Ribbon
As low as
$1.88 ea.
God Bless Banner Pink - Bite-Sized Chocolate Chip Cookies (3 oz., approx. 21 cookies) W/ Full Color Custom Sticker & Bow Choice
As low as
2.99 ea.
God Bless Simple Cross Photo Girl - Bite-Sized Chocolate Chip Cookies (3 oz., approx. 21 cookies) W/ Full Color Custom Sticker & Bow Choice
As low as
2.99 ea.
Communion Gold Chalice - Bite-Sized Chocolate Chip Cookies (3 oz., approx. 21 cookies) W/ Full Color Custom Sticker & Bow Choice
As low as
2.99 ea.

Custom First Communion Cookies

First Communion is one of the most important moments in a child's faith. Our custom First Communion cookies are a beautiful way to mark the occasion. Each cookie is printed with crosses, chalices, rosaries, and other faith-inspired designs using full-color edible ink. Every order is made fresh and ships in 1 to 2 business days. You can also schedule a future delivery date, so your cookies arrive exactly when you need them.

Perfect for Any First Communion Celebration

First Communion cookies are a great addition to any celebration, big or small. Families order them for all kinds of occasions, including:

  • Communion receptions at home or at the church hall
  • Dessert tables at family gatherings after the ceremony
  • Treats for guests attending the Communion mass
  • Celebrations coordinated in pink, white, blue, or gold color themes

Flavors and Packaging

We offer several cookie styles so you can find the right fit for your celebration.

Sugar Cookies: Come in round and square shapes. Designs are printed directly on the cookie using full-color edible ink. You can choose from crosses, florals, chalice designs, and styles made for both boys and girls.

Gourmet Cookies: Individually wrapped and come with a full-color personalized sticker. Available in flavors including Chocolate Chip, White Chocolate Macadamia Nut, Oatmeal Raisin, Chocolate Chip with M&Ms, and Variety Pack.

Mini Chocolate Chip Cookies: Approximately 14 mini cookies come in a bag with a custom sticker and ribbon. They are easy to hand out at larger gatherings.

Want a more polished look? Upgrade any cookie with a bag and bow for an individually wrapped presentation or choose a favor box for a gift-ready finish.

Shipping and Delivery

Getting your First Communion cookies there on time is easy. Here are a few things that make ordering simple:

Future Delivery Scheduling: Planning ahead? You can schedule your delivery date at checkout, so your cookies arrive right when you need them.

1 to 2 Business Day Processing: Our 1 to 2 business day processing means your cookies can be made and delivered even when time is short. Browse our First Communion collection and find the perfect design for your celebration.

Multi-Address Shipping: Sending cookies to multiple locations? You can ship to multiple addresses in a single order, which is perfect for out-of-town family members or guests who couldn't make the celebration.

We're Here to Help

Have questions about your First Communion cookie order? Our team is ready to help with everything from design options to delivery timing. Reach us at Sales@IncredibleCookies.com or call 1.888.568.3518.