Personalized Custom "Add Your Own Design" Direct Print on Square Sugar Cookies


1 sample allowed per order. Minimum 10 cookies per design.

  • Individually Wrapped custom-printed sugar cookies.
  • Each 3" cookie is handmade & freshly baked with top-quality ingredients.
  • Design printed directly on the cookie with food-safe, FDA-approved edible ink.
  • Sealed for freshness with a 3-month shelf life.
  • Ingredients: Flour, Sugar, Butter, Corn Syrup, Meringue Powder.
  • Please note our facility handles peanuts and tree nuts.
  • Choose Optional Personalized Favor Box OR Favor Bag & Colored Bow.
click on preview to view your personalization

Check In-home Delivery Date

Customer Reviews

Based on 13 reviews
Guests loved these cookies!

Tasted great, imprinting was better than expected and my guests loved them! Will order again for future events.

Charlie Barron

Cookies were great, unfortunately I ordered on a Monday and paid $200 for 2nd day delivery and they showed up on Friday so were too late!

Erika Lynn
Exceeded Expectation

The cookies were absolute perfection! They looked exactly how I wanted. I was blown away by the expediency of delivery. I tried another cookie distributor but was distressed when I opened the box and saw the ink on the cookies had been smeared. Not the case with Incredible Cookies! Also, the other companies quality was concrete, these were buttery and delicious and I could smell them when I opened the door upon delivery. (This is no exaggeration). I had a lot riding on this Amazon event and the cookies were an absolute hit. Thank you Incredible have a new and highly satisfied client and we look forward to ordering from you again.


Everything was as it should have been Beautifully done

Jennie Muzzy

We really wanted to love them but they were so bad it became a joke. The color wasn't printed correctly and was this weird faded blue rather than forest green and the cookies were so stale and hard, I wouldn't recommend. However their team is lovely and they were so helpful with letting us place the order. Thank you