Personalized Graduation "Stars And Cap" Direct Print on Round Sugar Cookies


1 sample allowed per order. Minimum 12 cookies per design.

  • Individually Wrapped custom-printed sugar cookies.
  • Each 3" cookie is handmade & freshly baked with top-quality ingredients.
  • Design printed directly on the cookie with food-safe, FDA-approved edible ink.
  • Sealed for freshness with a 3-month shelf life.
  • Ingredients: Flour, Sugar, Butter, Corn Syrup, Meringue Powder.
  • Please note our facility handles peanuts and tree nuts.
  • Choose Optional Personalized Favor Box OR Favor Bag & Colored Bow.
click on preview to view your personalization

Check In-home Delivery Date

Customer Reviews

Based on 6 reviews
Ashley Kincaid
Debbie is the best

Debbie at incredible cookies is the absolute sweetest. If you have any questions or concerns she promptly replies to your emails or phone calls.


The cookies came exactly as shown, wrapped and packed tight so no breakage during shipment. And they taste great!


Was a hit at graduation party

Colors are off/shipping expensive

Its a great idea, but the colors advertised on the website were much different. Also, in order to get the cookies somewhat fresh, I had to pay shipping that was almost as much as the cost of the cookies

Blair Chewning

(I sent this email the day I received the cookies, yet I received no response from your company.) The cookies I ordered for my grandson's graduation party arrived today, and I must say for the price I paid I am extremely disappointed. The stars are barely visible, the black mortar board is more dark gray than black, and most importantly, many of the designs weren't even centered on the cookie--shifted left or right but not centered. Having paid more than $3 per cookie, I was certainly expecting more. Your photos on the website make the cookie appear to have a glossy finish and the design is precision crisp and clear. Sadly, that is not the product I received--dull finish and details barely visible.

I always give companies I order from a prompt and positive review, but I don't feel able to offer that. Several friends were about to order on my recommendation, but I have called them today to tell them to rethink their orders until they see my cookies.