- Individually wrapped custom-printed sugar cookies.
- Each 4x2 inch cookie is handmade & freshly baked with top-quality ingredients.
- Design directly printed on royal icing with ...See More Info
Add Your Own Logo - Personalized Direct Print On Rectangle Sugar Cookie
1 sample allowed per order. Minimum 12 cookies per design.
Couldn't load pickup availability
Check In-home Delivery Date
J
The cookies looked just like our company logo! They tasted great too!
A
Looked exactly like what I submitted. They were packaged carefully and all arrived intact. They also tasted great!
C
I had made a large cookie order request (100 cookies) and was in need of an urgent turnaround (to be delivered within less than a week’s notice. I cannot adequately express how INCREDIBLY IMPRESSED I was with my on-time cookie delivery. Everything was beautifully and carefully packed, not one cookie was compromised nor broken. The photos on the cookies were excellent quality and the cookies were delicious! Thank you Incredible Cookies, you saved the day for my party!!
A
Had 2 dozen rectangular cookies made with a neighborhood logo for a local event. They were very popular.
M
We partnered with Incredible Cookies for customized logos on 50 cookies for a business meeting. The looked amazing and tasted great! Each cookie was carefully packaged to ensure they arrived on time and unharmed. Everyone was very impressed!
M
Cookies showed up on time. Mostly bought based on fast shipping time and individual wrapping to stay fresh but they were tasty too! I bought a dozen and they put in a 13th which was great to be able to try one before my event. I did have some black text on a blue background which was a little difficult to read so just be aware of things like that when making your design choices, things that look good on a screen don’t always translate well to icing. It actually looked better in pictures than it did by eye. Would definitely buy again for future events
A
Every month, parents donate cookies to support our Midshipmen at the U.S. Merchant Marine Academy. I have donated wonderful cookies from Incredible Cookies many times, but this month's donation was a big hit with many parents wanting to know where I ordered from. Incredible Cookies did a terrific job transferring the picture that I provided to the cookies - they looked amazing! Thank you!
K
I ordered custom cookies for a special event at work. We have 2 offices on the East Coast and I had them ship the same order (4 dozen) to each office. They were a HUGE hit! It was for a very special week at work that culminated in a lovely lunch and, of course, the fabulous cookies. I was truly amazed at how awesome they turned out. The color was perfect and the artwork I sent looked exactly the same on the cookie. They were packaged so nicely and not a single one arrived broken. Everyone loved them and thought they were so special! I will definitely be ordering more for future events. I thought the price point was terrific as well - the whole process was smooth from start to finish. I was really pleased with the results (blown away is more like it!). Thank you, Incredible Cookies!
T
The group absolutely loved these custom cookies. We will surely do this again in the future for other events.
A
My client was impressed! We had the logo and mascot printed on the cookies. Definitely will be ordering again!
A
Our cookies arrived on time and packaged well--- there was no broken pieces or unusable cookies. We did one cookie with our logo on the sticker of the package and one where the logo was printed on the cookie itself and they both looked fantastic and tasted great too.
K
We ordered these for a celebration of our annual giving campaign for our emplolyees. They were gone in an instant! High quality and amazing presentation. Well packed so there was zero spoilage!
Thank you for your great review! We are so happy that your event was a success and that we could be a small part of it!
L
You won't find a better tasting cookie with you this quality of artwork
L
Best Cookies I've had with custom artwork
A
Excellent customer service!
C
Add Your Own Logo - Personalized Direct Print On Rectangle Sugar Cookie
M
Add Your Own Logo - Personalized Direct Print On Rectangle Sugar Cookie
K
Quick delivery and exactly what I wanted.
K
Great Presentation, shipped with care. No broken cookies! but the cookies were hard.
A
Cookies are dry and too sweet
S
Absolutely delicious cookies! They were fresh and full of flavor. The ordering process was easy, and even though there was an issue with the timing on a previous order, the customer service was great and they helped make it right. Definitely recommend and would order again!
k
Came out beautiful
S
I recently placed an order with this online cookie company, and I couldn’t be happier! The cookies arrived on time and were packaged perfectly to ensure freshness. Each cookie was delicious, soft, and packed with flavor—just like homemade. It’s clear that they use quality ingredients and take pride in their baking. Definitely a great experience.
H
I went into this fully prepared to be disappointed — online cookie orders can be a gamble. But wow… these cookies didn’t just show up, they showed off. Perfect taste, perfect look, and delivered like they were precious cargo. Consider me officially converted. I’m absolutely ordering again!
H
Add Your Own Logo - Personalized Direct Print On Rectangle Sugar Cookie
J
OMG! Incredible Cookies knocked it out of the park! Photo was perfect on the cookie and they are DELICIOUS! I can’t wait to use them again for my niece’s bridal shower! Five stars all the way!
